Since publication in 1993, the first edition has sold nearly 20,000 copies and
continues to sell well. However, since the book was begun in 1990, much has
changed in the world, especially in the U.S. for whose readers the book was
primarily written, that demands this update of the book, which we now publish
under the title Four Practical Revolutions in
Management—Systems for Creating Unique Organizational Capability
Continuing evolution of business needs and business improvement
methods. The first edition of our book in
1993 was nominally on about the why and the how of Total Quality Management
(TQM). TQM by then had developed over nearly 40 years, first in the U.S., then
in Japan, and then again in the U.S. Historically, TQM was focused on improving
the quality of products and service and doing so with maximum efficiency. In
other words, it was focused on quality assurance—the management of quality. Neither the
first edition of this book nor this second edition puts much emphasis on this
traditional focus of TQM on quality assurance. There are many other books on TQM
narrowly defined as quality assurance.
By the time we drafted the first edition
of this book the focus of the methods known as TQM was beginning to move from
the management of quality to the quality of
management—dealing with the ongoing
improvement of the way an organization is managed in a rapidly changing world.
Thus, the focus of our first edition was on management and not limited to
product and service quality. In fact, shortly after the first edition was
published in 1993, we began speaking and writing about TQM as Total Quality
of Management rather than Total Quality Management; in the last several
years, when we were trying to be precise, we have begun to speak of
TQofM
rather than TQM.
Nearly another
decade has passed since we began to write the first edition, and the evolution
of the problems organizations face has continued. Beyond assuring product and
service quality and more generally continuing to improve the way they operate
their business, many organizations find it necessary to redefine their business
upon occasion. To these ends they need to create an appropriate management
system or organization for their own situation. In fact, during the time since
the first edition, we have come to see the TQofM methods we were teaching as
being aimed at helping a company create its appropriate unique organizational capability
Also, over the past decade or
two, organizations of every type have come to think of themselves more as
businesses. Once upon a time only for-profit manufacturing and service companies
were thought of as being in
business. These days, at least in the U.S.,
there is increasing pressure for government, the military, health care
organizations, schools and colleges, charities, and even churches to operate in
a more business-like fashion. There is loud complaint when the government of a
state or a health care organization “does not operate like a business" or “is
not accountable."
In this new edition, we describe methods to address these new needs. In particular, we
describe methods to address the needs of organizations (a) to have a dynamic
(not static) implementation strategy, (b) to plan for ongoing exploration and
discovery and not just for execution, and (c) to diffuse not just within teams
or within organizations but in a reinforcing way among individuals, teams,
organizations, and across society. Addressing this combination of needs is a
unique aspect of our book.
New
case studies. The widespread use by
companies of the methods described in the first edition and newer methods since
the first edition has resulted in many new case studies being available for use
in the second edition.
Emphasis on integration with other methods. The U.S. has had to suffer through another decade of the
business press and business gurus declaring that one important management
advance after another was first the panacea and then was dead. When this book
was first written, TQM was the panacea, and then it was declared dead. Then came
Business Process Reengineerg and then Systems Thinking. Lean Production was
promoted for a while. Astonishingly, as this book is being revised, Six Sigma is
becoming all the rage, as if it hadn’t been a key component in Motorola’s award
winning TQM implementation in the late 1980s. It is entirely natural that new
business ideas get put forward. However, it is counter-productive to see them
(especially to promote them) as being in conflict with each other or each new
method replacing the older methods. Once one reconciles the vocabulary
differences, there is usually considerable overlap among the supposedly
competing methods; and progress in all fields of human endeavor typically
depends on newer methods building on or being added to the best parts of older
methods. We believe that from the sets of management methods available, managers
of companies must select the parts of each set that apply to their company and
integrate them into a system appropriate for their company. We call this
designing integrated management
systems, and it is a thread that runs through
this revision.
Dodging the uninformed perception that “TQM is dead".
Some managers and students of management
believe that “TQM is dead." Of course, the methods of TQM are very much alive.
Many of the best companies use the methods of TQM, although in some cases they
may not talk about them as being TQM. In fact, many TQM methods (for example,
ongoing process improvement, customer focus and employee involvement) have
become so accepted that they are merely viewed as part of modern management, and
companies that didn’t use the methods would find themselves at a competitive
disadvantage. And, as already mentioned, the methods continue to evolve and
improve, often in synthesis with other “name methods."
Nonetheless, so we can quickly move to
teaching the use of the methods and avoid some of the distraction and mind set
around “TQM is dead," we decided to drop “TQM" from the book’s title. Without
the ability to use TQM in the title, we now use as our title the old subtitle of
the book, Four Practical Revolutions in Management, which alludes to the four
areas of skill development covered in the first edition and in this new edition
and that make up TQM or TQofM: customer focus, continuous improvement, total participation
and societal networking.
Changes in vocabulary. Therefore, TQM will be unavailable to us as an abbreviation for the
principles, methods and practices contained in the four areas of skill
development. Unfortunately, our newer version, TQofM, seems a little awkward and
might still be confused with TQM. Therefore, in this book we will use words such
as to make organizational
change, to
do organizational learning, to do organizational improvement, and implement organizational change
and improvement rather than to implement TQM or
implement TQofM; and we will refer to methods
or practices of organizational change,
etc. rather than methods or practices of TQM
or TQofM.
We will use organizational change and
organizational change and improvement
(not TQM) to refer to changing the total
quality of management to develop an organization’s unique capability. These
organizational changes may be incremental improvements, breakthroughs from
existing business practice, or the entrance into entirely new businesses.
In phrases such as organizational
change we mean organization as a synonym for any business or non-profit entity
such as a corporation, company, university, or society that might use the
methods of this book to improve its overall management system. (In fact, much of
the time we use business rather casually to refer to any for-profit or not-for-profit
organization.)
Removing “American" from the title. The first edition of this book has been translated formally into Spanish,
French, and Portuguese and has been used as a textbook in courses in the rest of
Western Europe (particularly Germany) and Scandinavia (including Finland), Latin
America, and in several Asian countries (including Japan). The book has also
been informally translated and used in courses in China. Since the content of
the book is not limited to use in the U.S., including the word
American in the title was an
unnecessary limitation and confusion.
Increased emphasis on theme of systematic development of skill.
The first edition of this book had a
clear theme of the described methods being for the systematic development of
skill in managers, teams, individuals, and organizations. The new edition puts
greater emphasis on this theme and on systems for combining the several areas of
skill development.
Supporting materials. The
first edition of this book was used as the textbook for a variety of college and
company training courses. In support of these courses, a parallel set of
teaching material has been created, including step-by-step manuals on specific
methods, quick reference cards, homework assignments, and in-class exercises.
Some of these ancillary materials are included in the second edition and some
are referenced. In addition, the Journal of
the Center for Quality of Management, which
was started in parallel with the drafting of the first edition of this book, has
been publishing for nine year and is now on-line on the World Wide Web. This
edition references a number of the papers and cases studies in that on-line
archive. Finally, we plan to have a Web site (www.cqm.org/4prim) in support of
this book—at minimum, a list of errors and corrections.
What
we have not changed. While we have
dropped some case studies from the first edition, we have kept other old cases
studies. Good case studies can remain useful examples, even in some cases where
they are a decade old and the company described no longer exists or operates in
the same way. In general, we see case studies primarily as a way to clarify the
practical use. We do not use case studies to prove the validity of a method.
Good methods can fail. Bad methods can succeed. What works at one time may fail
at another time, for a variety of reasons.
This second edition is
still intended to be a textbook for college courses and courses outside of
colleges aimed at executives and managers. It is also intended to be read and
referenced by CEOs and other organizational change agents who are engaged in
improving the way their organizations (however large or small) operate. We aim
to provide more than motivation for change and pat answers for how to accomplish
change. We are trying to provide enough theory, practical methods, and examples
to enable readers to develop their own theories for the future structure and
processes of their organizations, to try them in their organizations, and over
time to make them work. To support the practical use of the content of our book,
we include many references to related works, both to provide pointers to
additional information and to acknowledge our sources.